Handling DEFIANCE
Defiance can be one of the most challenging behaviors for parents to navigate.
When your highly sensitive child digs in their heels or refuses to cooperate, it’s easy to feel frustrated or unsure what to do.
But it’s important to remember that defiance is often a signal that your child is overwhelmed, scared, or struggling to express their needs.
Highly sensitive children, in particular, experience the world deeply. This heightened sensitivity can make them more prone to defiance, especially when they feel misunderstood or out of control.
The good news?
With the right strategies, you can approach defiance in a way that builds connection, teaches your child important skills, and helps them feel safe and understood.
Here are five tips for handling defiance with your highly sensitive child:
1. Look Beneath the Behavior
Behavior is always an attempt to get an unmet need met.
Get curious what might be going on for your child. Ask yourself: What might be driving this behavior? Are they tired, hungry, overwhelmed, or feeling disconnected from you?
Highly sensitive children are more likely to act out when their emotional tank is empty or when their environment feels chaotic. Instead of focusing solely on the defiance, try to address the underlying need.
For example:
If your child refuses to clean up their toys, consider whether they’re feeling overwhelmed by the mess. Offering to clean up together can make the task feel more manageable.
If they’re defiant about leaving the park, acknowledge their feelings: “It’s hard to stop playing when you’re having so much fun. Let’s come up with a plan for something fun to do at home.”
2. Stay Calm and Regulate Yourself
Your child’s defiance can trigger strong emotions in you, but meeting their resistance with anger or frustration often escalates the situation. As a parent, your calm presence is key to helping your child regulate their emotions.
When you feel yourself getting frustrated, take a deep breath, pause, and remind yourself that defiance is not personal—it’s a sign that your child is struggling. Responding with empathy and calmness can diffuse tension and create an opportunity for connection.
For example:
Instead of saying, “Why can’t you just listen?” try: “I see you’re really upset right now. Let’s take a moment to calm down together.”
3. Give Choices to Empower Them
Highly sensitive children often feel overwhelmed when they lack a sense of control. Providing choices can reduce power struggles and help your child feel more independent.
Offer simple, age-appropriate options that still align with the boundaries you’ve set.
For example:
Instead of demanding, “Get dressed now!” try: “Would you like to wear your blue shirt or your red shirt today?”
Instead of saying, “It’s time to do your homework,” try: “Do you want to start with math or reading?”
This approach helps your child feel empowered while still ensuring the task gets done.
4. Set Clear and Gentle Boundaries
While choices and flexibility are important, boundaries provide your child with a sense of safety and structure. Highly sensitive children thrive when they know what to expect, but they need those boundaries communicated with kindness.
Be consistent and clear about the rules, and explain them in a way that connects to your child’s values or emotions. Avoid harsh discipline, which can overwhelm their sensitive nature and lead to shutdowns.
For example:
Instead of, “Stop yelling right now!” try: “I know you’re upset, but yelling hurts my ears. Let’s take a deep breath and use calmer words to talk about this.”
5. Focus on Connection Before Correction
Defiance often stems from a feeling of disconnection. Before trying to correct your child’s behavior, focus on rebuilding your relationship in the moment. When your child feels loved, understood, and safe, they are more likely to cooperate.
Ways to connect during defiance:
Empathize: “I can see this is really hard for you. I’m here to help.”
Use physical connection: Offer a gentle touch, hug, or sit close to them if they’re open to it.
Validate their feelings: “It’s okay to feel upset. Let’s figure this out together.”
Once they feel connected, they’ll be more receptive to problem-solving and making amends.
Final Thoughts
Defiance in highly sensitive children is not a sign of “bad behavior” but a signal that they need your help. By addressing the root cause of the defiance, staying calm, and prioritizing connection, you can guide your child through these challenging moments with compassion and understanding.
Remember, every moment of defiance is an opportunity to teach your child emotional regulation, problem-solving, and self-awareness. And along the way, you’re building a strong, trusting relationship that will support them for years to come.
If you’re struggling with defiance in your home, I’d love to help.
We can turn this around and create cooperation and connection.
You can schedule a free call with me using the “Schedule a Free Call Button” to get individualized support, or download my free guide, “Debunking the 5 Myths of Parenting a Highly Sensitive Child” to get concrete strategies that can help.
I f you are the parent of a highly sensitive or strong-willed kid, stuck in constant power struggles, meltdowns, or angry outbursts, I’d like to share something with you. This is my method how I transform families. I’d like to share exactly how I take families from constant power struggles and meltdowns, to peace, harmony and connection . In only 12 weeks. Working one-on-one with parents. Via weekly Zoom calls. Here is What I Do: Step #1 : We transform your listening, so your child learns how to listen more respectfully to you, too. Step #2 : We strengthen self-empathy & self-compassion, so you feel connected, confident, and joyful as a parent. Step #3 : We stop patterns leading to big explosions and dysregulation. This means your child has fewer meltdowns, and you can actually enjoy your child, and stop walking on eggshells. Step #4 : We teach you how to set boundaries peacefully, so your child behaves better, listens more, and argues less. Step #5 : We stop sibling fighting, so your children get along better, and you don’t need to constantly referee fights. Step #6 : We focus on communicating differently, so your kid is more open to feedback and correction, and less likely to shut down, lash out, or become defensive. Step #7 : We learn how sensory challenges and your child’s high sensitivity might be creating challenging behaviors--so we can make life easier for you both. Step #8 : We get you and your partner on the same page, so you can stop disagreeing about parenting and start supporting one another. Step #9 : We celebrate your child’s unique personality, so you can enjoy your child, and stop feeling stressed, anxious or fearful about their future. Step #10 : We focus on your needs as a parent, so you feel less stressed, more calm, and joyful. So then what? What happens next? How will you feel? First, you will feel calmer. More confident. You’ll enjoy your child more. You’ll see your child in a more positive, hopeful way. You’ll connect better. Your child will listen more. Behave better. Have fewer meltdowns or big emotional explosions. You’ll notice your child using words to express their emotions and needs in healthier ways. You and your child will both feel less reactive, less bothered by little issues, and more able to find joy and connection. If you have a partner, the two of you will feel more like a supportive parenting team, and less likely to feel criticized, blamed, or judged for your parenting. You’ll have a shared vision and goal in parenting, and understand how to support each other better. You’ll feel more confident setting peaceful limits, and your children will be better able to hear you say no and tolerate the feelings that come with that. You will be able to go places that you might not have taken your child in the past, for fear of what might happen. If you have multiple children, they will fight less, get along better, and learn how to handle conflict between themselves more. If you are highly sensitive, you will better understand how to support your own needs as a parent, so you are less likely to feel overwhelmed and overstimulated, and more likely to feel energized and at peace. If your child is highly sensitive, you’ll better understand how to create a life that supports your child’s unique needs, and know how to make life function better for everyone. ******* If you are ready for support with your highly sensitive or strong-willed child’s big emotions or power struggles, you don’t have to do this alone. Let’s chat, and I can share more about how I can help create harmony. Schedule a free call with me today.
Many common challenges parents face with children misbehaving or being oppositional are actually signs of hidden sensory issues. This includes challenges like meltdowns, picky eating, hyperactivity, and resistance to hygiene—these can all be signs of hidden sensory issues. Discover practical ways parents can support their child’s sensory needs with empathy and simple accommodations.
Discover 5 common struggles empath parents face and how to turn your deep sensitivity into your greatest parenting strength. Includes a free support call offer.
These are the parenting ideas that help me to show up when life is messy. I call them my parenting mantras. How did I come up with these?
They arise from my experience as a mom for 16 years; my experience helping parents create peace and connection as a parent coach for 8 years; and my experience helping parents of NICU babies handle new parenthood and a child’s health crisis as a pediatrician in the NICU for 20 years.
These mantras that have helped me through my own struggles, and I think they can help you as you navigate parenting struggles, and seek to create a more peaceful, connected home as well.
Sometimes in our most stressful parenting moments, we can feel like we are not on the same page with our partner, or even that we are on opposing teams. This can happen because we have different parenting styles which can become more accentuated when a child is highly sensitive, or has big emotional reactions. Sometimes what appears to be a parenting challenge is actually a relationship challenge instead. Here are some common dynamics I see that are actually relationship challenges disguised as a parenting challenge.
Does your strong-willed or highly sensitive child meltdown with anything unexpected, refuse to get dressed, or lash out when you say “no”? Despite what it seems, they’re not trying to give you a hard time. They’re just HAVING a hard time. Many highly sensitive children struggle with their behavior in ways that looks like defiance and resistance, but it’s actually fear, anxiety and emotional overwhelm. By understanding this, we can find better solutions that help our kids to cooperate and have better behavior.
You make a small request of your strong-willed or highly sensitive child, and you get defiance, arguments, and power struggles. What’s going on? It’s NOT what you think. Many kids who look defiant are actually kids struggling to transitions to a new activity. Transitions are challenging for everyone, but for some children, because of their brain wiring, transitions are more challenging, creating major power struggles. Here’s what cures defiance.
For highly sensitive children especially, punishments often backfire, making behavior and your relationship worse than ever. How can we discipline highly sensitive children in effective ways that are based on trust, learning, and maintaining a close, connected relationship with their parents? We want to avoid punishments, and instead set boundaries with empathy and kindness, practice collaborative problem-solving, and do emotion coaching.
Do you have an argumentative or defiant kid? Many of the families I coach do.
If you have an argumentative child who needs to be in control, who is resistant and defiant with even small requests, who refuses to go outside his comfort zone, or who struggles with disappointment or embarrassment, this explains why your child is so challenging, and how to help them be more flexible and cooperative.
Overstimulation happens when the amount of sensory input is too much, leading to feelings of exhaustion, overwhelm, or emotional shut down. These symptoms are more likely in highly sensitive children and parents, who are more affected by sensory inputs. How can we help avoid and manage feelings of overstimulation? How can we help our children who struggle with overstimulation?
